Tuesday, May 26, 2015

A Message to Frank...

You have, in the past, posted many comments. Some I put through, several I don't. Allow me to explain something that you might not be aware of...this is not a public blog...this is a personal one.

I started it about 8 years ago first to calm myself, to express into a huge void that is the Internet, my innermost concerns and fears. I couldn't say them to my first son...not even to my second...as they went into the army and out of the home in which they had grown.

I doubt I'll be able to say these same fears for my youngest son, who goes into the army in a few months...too few months. There is never enough time to prepare emotionally for that moment when you know you have completely lost all control over your child's destiny. It happens more gradually in the country of my birth; but here in Israel, at least for boys, it is sudden and it is shocking. One night he is sleeping in his bed, fighting with his siblings, refusing to take out the garbage, making you laugh over something, reaching to take a bag from you so you don't have to carry it, picking up his little sister and tossing her high...and then, he's all grown up, gone for most of the time.

So I started this blog never considering others would read it. And was shocked to find that many do; that there are many parents who are experiencing the same thing...and not even just here in Israel. And there are people about to experience it, or who went through it. Or there are people who love Israel and hunger for any word about life there. Or there are people who are curious about this place Israel that gets to much media coverage, so much beyond the proportional size and population.

And then there are others, sort of like you, who like to argue, like to point out injustices where there are none (Arabic is an option in many Israeli schools - English, French, Arabic...my oldest daughter learned it for a while but dropped it).

So, Frank...here's an example of why I write - below is a post about Israel being condemned by...wait...let me check which UN body it was this time...ah yes, the UN's World Health Organization has condemned Israel yet again...

And finally, Frank, you asked why I do not post your comments. The simple answer is because I don't have to...this is my blog. You can start your own. I welcome many discussions but others, as is my right, I prefer not to begin. I never get tired of explaining about Israel; I do, at times, get tired of being put in a position where it is assumed I am justifying something that is wrong, rationalizing something away. My country has much to be proud of and very little, compared to ALL of our neighbors, for which we should feel ashamed. Without balance, there can be no discussion. I see no balance in your comments.

Sometimes, I put comments through and then answer them; sometimes I leave it to others to respond. Sometimes, I choose not to put them through at all...my right.

Sometimes, I post them, like this: Mahmood Says...

Sometimes, I put them all together... like this: Comments on Comments...

I hope you'll take the time to read the following UN Watch alert and perhaps even comment on it. I can't promise to publish all your comments but I'll be happy to respond to those that are not filled with unbalanced accusations, ignorance, or attacks.

UN Watch Briefing
Latest from the United Nations
 Vol. 534 |  May 22, 2015         
UN casts Israel as worst violator of health rights in the world
 Above: Israel's army team of medics recently treated 1,600 victims of the Nepal earthquake.
By Hillel Neuer
As Israeli hospitals continue their life-saving treatment for escalating numbers of wounded Syrians fleeing to the Golan from the Assad regime’s barbaric attacks, the U.N. reached new heights of absurdity today by adopting a draft resolution portraying Israel as violating the health rights of Syrians in the Golan.
By a vote of 104 to 4, with 6 abstentions and 65 absent, the Jewish state was the only country in the world to be singled out on Wednesday by the annual assembly of the U.N.’s World Health Organization. The decision was ratified today in Geneva in a final reading by the plenary. 
The resolution adopts two reports heaping blame upon Israel for allegedly violating the health rights of both the Palestinians and Druze residents of the Golan, and constituted the 2015 assembly’s only treatment of a specific country situation.
There was no debate on the health of the Yemeni people now under indiscriminate Saudi bombardment, no mention at all of the 1,850 Yemenis killed, the 7,394 wounded, and the 545,000 displaced, many of whom are desperate to find food.
On the contrary, the representative of Saudi Arabia’s theocracy took the floor, without any sense of shame, to denounce “Israeli intransigence,” and to beseech “all peace loving states” to adopt the distorted and politicized resolution.
The despotic regime must have felt especially emboldened as the gathering took place adjacent to the Human Rights Council, where Saudi Arabia sits as a full member, elected in 2013 by more than two-thirds of the UN General Assembly.
All of this while the Wahhabist regime advertises the hiring of eight more executioners to carry out beheadings, which have spiraled this year to more than double the amount in 2014. ISIS can only be jealous of what this UNHRC member has achieved.
Nor is this year’s UN health assembly holding a single debate on the health rights of Ukranian civilians caught in a war with Russian-backed militias. The 6,000 people killed, and the one million displaced, are simply of no interest.
Preoccupied by the alleged sins of Israelis, the UN turned a blind eye to the latest warning by health experts, reported in Newsweek, that Ukraine is in imminent danger of experiencing the first polio epidemic Europe has seen for decades. “Millions of children are at risk from a range of crippling or fatal infectious diseases, including measles, diphtheria and rubella,” said the report. Yet the UN couldn’t be bothered—and Russia gleefully voted for the PLO-drafted condemnation of Israel.
Resolution absurdly condemns Israel for violating health
rights of Syrians, ignores Assad atrocities

Most absurd of all, though, was that the resolution falsely claimed a dire need for “health-related technical assistance” for “the Syrian population in the occupied Syrian Golan” — who in fact have excellent treatment — and said nothing about the Syrian population being slaughtered in Syria.
Instead, the scapegoating of Israel—in the form of a special debate, two lopsided reports, the resolution, and the publication of country submissions—provided a UN platform for Assad’s murderous regime.
“The Israeli occupation authorities continue to experiment on Syrian and Arab prisoners with medicines and drugs and to inject them with pathogenic viruses,” wrote Syria, in a submission laced with anti-Semitic conspiracy tropes, yet circulated as an official UN document on the conference agenda.
Unable to deny Israel’s medical treatment of wounded Syrians, the regime concocted another plot: Israel deliberately heals regime opponents so that they can “resume their subversive terrorist activities directed against the country’s peaceful citizens and its infrastructure.”
Had the EU wanted, they could have set the record straight, and taken a stand against such base demonization of the Jewish state.
Disgracefully, however, Britain, France, Germany and all other EU states joined the jackals by voting for today’s resolution.
The EU states could have introduced their own resolution about how Syria has killed more than 200,000 of their own people, including 20,000 children, caused three million to flee as refugees, and displaced another six million within Syria itself, amounting to the utter destruction of the health rights of the Syrian people.
Yet the EU was silent. Instead, it justified its vote by claiming that the resolution was “technical.” It’s the old Brussels-Ramallah wink-and-nod game: the PLO submits a more inflammatory text at the beginning, knowing it will be revised later to allow the Europeans to pretend they achieved a “balanced” text. Israel is then expected to celebrate that it has been lynched with a lighter rope.
UN should single out Israel: as a beacon of humanity  
The truth is, the UN health assembly should single out Israel—as a beacon of humanity.
The UN should single out Israel because if you walk into any Israeli hospital or clinic, you will see it replete with Palestinians receiving world-class medical treatment.
And this was true even this past summer while Hamas fired thousands of rockets at Israel, and placed their terrorist command center under the Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza, a despicable abuse of health rights unmentioned by the world health assembly.
The UN should single out Israel because its doctors have created the amazing “Save A Child’s Heart” program, which has provided life-saving cardiac surgery to more than 3,400 children from 48 different countries, training doctors and nurses from China to Zanzibar. About half the patients are Muslims from the West Bank, Gaza and other Arab countries.
The UN should single out Israel because it was a world leader in responding to the deadly earthquake in Nepal, sending a 260-member army team of medics and search and rescue experts who treated 1,600 victims, including 85 surgeries and eight infant deliveries.
And the UN should single out Israel because its Nobel Prize-winning scientists and innovative biotech companies have become global innovators who create therapeutic products, diagnostic tools and revolutionary drug-delivery techniques benefiting people all over the world.
Yet so long as the UN instead descends into irrationalism, scapegoating the Jewish state for all the world’s health problems just as medieval Europe accused the Jews of poisoning the wells, the organization betrays the cause of humanity and the noble principles upon which it was founded.
Hillel Neuer is the executive director of UN Watch.

To support the vital work of UN Watch, please contribute here.

UN Watch is an independent human rights group founded in 1993 in Geneva, Switzerland,
receiving no financial support from any organization or government. We rely on the
generosity of charitable donations. Thank you for your support.

tel: (41-22) 734-1472 • fax: (41-22) 734-1613


Mordechai Y. Scher said...

I actually find it quite prestigious that the UN has either Kafka or George Orwell to write their resolutions.

On a related note, the resolution authors should come to Katzrin. Quite a few UN personnel living in Katzrin. You can see their cars in driveways on every side of town. Several of them were in the cafe where I had breakfast. Funny how they're all living in Israel; and none of them choose to be in Lebanon or Syria, eh?

toni said...

The UN is ridiculous and a embarrassment.

Anonymous said...

Ignore the " Franks" of this world. There are so many... Continue doing what you are doing for YOU . I really admire you- so do many others.

Copyright Statement

Everything on this site is protected and copyrighted according to Israeli and international laws. Violators WILL be prosecuted.

For permission to use pictures or text from this site, please write to: info@paulasays.com.